I have been wanting to share this delicious bacon wrapped jalapeno recipe with you all for a while now. I made a batch a few days ago so that I could take some pictures and to make sure I had exact measurements. The best part is you can make them mild or spicy, depending on your personal taste. Either way, they would be a great addition to any Super Bowl or Playoff Party!
We used to just cook these on the grill, but about a year ago I decided to make them in the oven to see how they would come out baking them instead. We have made these many times while camping, but I decided that they might also make a great football party snack or appetizer. I was right!
Let me just warn you, every time I make these, I cannot believe how freakin’ delicious they are! I seriously recommend making twice as many as you think you want…believe me, once you and your guests taste these bacon wrapped jalapenos, you are going to want more!
My Popper Woes
When I was a kid I loved jalapeno poppers. I always got the ones filled with cheddar cheese. But then something happened a while back…someone decided that poppers should have cream cheese and not cheddar. This has greatly disturbed me.
A lot of places had the choice of cream cheese or cheddar back in the day, so I had tried both. The cheddar filled jalapeno poppers were way better. Cream cheese has such a mild flavor, you almost can’t taste it among the flavors of the jalapeno and deep fried breading. Cheddar has a more distinct flavor that held its own within the delightful little package.
But, alas, I have maybe found one or two cheddar filled poppers in the last 15 or 20 years. So sad…
Grown Up Poppers
Now that I am older, and I don’t eat many deep fried treats, I needed to find a way to satisfy my popper cravings. So we came up with this delicious jalapeno popper variation.
I don’t know that these are really a lower calorie treat than the deep fried poppers from my childhood, but at least they are made with all natural ingredients. Plus they are much fancier. They are definitely grown up poppers.
These are the best bacon wrapped jalapenos, they embrace both kinds of poppers from when I was a kid. They have cheddar and cream cheese! Now we can all be happy.
This recipe makes 20 Bacon Wrapped Jalapenos
- One 8 oz package of Cream Cheese
- 1 cup shredded Sharp Cheddar Cheese
- 10 jalapenos
- 2 green onions- finely chopped
- 6 large cloves garlic- finely chopped
- 20 strips of bacon
Generally when we make these we make the filling ahead of time. This last time, I made it about 3 hours in advance, so that when I was ready to make them I could just put them together and cook.
If you can, let the cream cheese sit out for a little while to soften up. It makes it a lot easier to stir. Depending on the temp in your house, let it sit out for 30-60 minutes for proper softening.
When ready, you will want to combine the cream cheese, cheddar, garlic, and green onions in a bowl and stir together. Last time I made it, I forgot to soften the cream cheese, so it was harder to combine the ingredients, but I still got it done.
I just used a large metal spoon and kept folding and smooshing the ingredients together against the sides of the bowl until everything appeared pretty evenly distributed. It only took a couple minutes.
I also wanted to mention that it may seem like a lot of garlic, but when it is in there with all the other ingredients it gets lost if you don’t use this amount. I have used less, and been disappointed that I couldn’t taste the garlic at all, so don’t make that mistake.
If you are super sensitive to spicy foods, you may want to use disposable gloves for this part. I don’t, but I know some people like to. Just make sure you wash your hands really well when you are done so you don’t accidentally get any spicy residue in your eye later.
Ok, you want to cut off the stem part, then cut your jalapenos in half long ways. Try to make them as even as possible.
Then you want to remove the stuff inside of the pepper, removing the seeds and the membrane holding the seeds. Each jalapeno should then leave you with two little jalapeno boats.
If you want your bacon wrapped jalapenos to be on the spicy side, you can leave the seeds in the jalapeno halves. Another way to spice them up is to just add the seeds to the cream cheese mix. I actually just saved the seeds for myself, and basically dipped my fresh and hot bacon wrapped jalapeno in them between bites. I am the only person in my house that likes spicy food, so I have to give my food some fiery love on the side.
Fill the Peppers
Ok, so now you have your filling and your jalapeno boats ready to go. This part is pretty straight forward. You want to spoon the filling into the pepper halves. Make sure to fill the jalapenos up. You want the filling to completely fill the pepper, with no gaps. And it the filling should stick out over the top of each jalapeno about 1/4 inch (6-7 cm) or so.
Once you have them all filled, you are almost done!
Alright, now for the last step in the assembly line. Take a strip of bacon and wrap it in a spiral around a filled jalapeno and set them on a foiled pan for baking. If you are going to cook them on the grill you do the same, except you will end up putting the foil on the grill. Then do the same for each of your filled jalapeno halves.
To make sure they don’t unravel during cooking I put two toothpicks in each jalapeno. One at each end where the end of the bacon is on each side.
If you are baking your bacon wrapped jalapenos you will want to preheat your oven to 350 degrees. Then cook them for about 25 mins. Cook them until the bacon looks good and done. A little of the cheese might ooze out, but it shouldn’t be very much.
I recommend checking on them at about 15 mins to make sure the bacon is cooking evenly on all sides of your pan. If one side seems to be cooking faster than the other, turn the pan around.
If you are grilling yours, just put the foil on the grill. Keep an eye on them and turn them as necessary. You will want to make the a boat with the foil, so that the bacon grease isn’t running off. It will cause flare ups. If this happens just pull the foil to a different area of the grill.
I just use tongs to tug the foil around to where I want it, and to turn or rotate the jalapenos as necessary. Cooking it on the grill is definitely more hands on than in the oven. But it totally works, and smells great too! Just cook them until the bacon looks good and done. Depending on the heat level of your grill it should take about 20 to 30 minutes.
The Best Bacon Wrapped Jalapeno Recipe Wrap Up
You will love these. I guarantee it! They are really great for any occasion. I just had some a few days ago, and I already want to make more.
I can’t wait for all of you to get the chance to enjoy this delicious treat! If you have any questions, comments, or suggestions, feel free to let me know, either by leaving a comment below or you can use the contact form.
Also, please take some time to check out the rest of the website from some other great recipes, reviews, my favorite Hot Sauce recommendations, and lots of interesting information on the health benefits of chili peppers.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. Purchasing through any provided links supports our cause and has no effect on the cost of products or services. Thank you for your loyal readership.